Only Half of Canadian Employers Say They Effectively Manage Benefits Costs

Gallagher report highlights growing pressure to get more value from benefits spending
Canadian employers are taking a closer look at the value of their employee benefits as costs rise and workforce needs evolve, according to Gallagher’s 2026 Workforce Trends Series — Benefits Benchmarks report.
Based on responses from 674 Canadian employers, the report finds that only half believe their organization effectively manages benefits costs. Yet 61% still plan benefits year to year, underscoring the need for a longer-term approach to setting priorities and directing investments.
“Employers are no longer asking only whether they offer enough benefits, they’re asking whether those benefits deliver enough value,” said Sarah Beech, CEO of Gallagher’s Benefits & HR Consulting Division in Canada. “With rising costs and employee needs changing, year-to-year decision-making is no longer enough. Employers need better data and a longer-term view of where their investments can have the greatest impact."
GLP-1s put pharmacy-benefit sustainability in focus
Prescription drugs remain a leading cost concern. The high cost of specialty drugs ranks first among employers’ healthcare cost-management challenges, followed by non-specialty prescription drugs and medical services.
To manage spending, 65% of employers require generic or least-cost alternatives, 38% use prior authorization based on drug classification and/or cost, and 34% impose dispensing-fee maximums.
GLP-1 medications are adding complexity to these decisions. Generic alternatives may lower the cost per prescription, but greater demand could make utilization a more significant driver of overall spending. At the same time, new indications and ongoing clinical research may broaden demand, creating uncertainty about future plan costs.
“GLP-1s illustrate the challenge employers face across their benefit programs,” Beech said. “Innovation can create meaningful opportunities for employees, but coverage decisions need to consider utilization, clinical value, workforce needs and long-term affordability. It isn’t simply a question of whether to provide coverage, but how to provide it sustainably.”
Emotional and financial wellbeing gain attention
Employers are also broadening their approach to wellbeing. In 2026, 76% report an increased focus on emotional wellbeing, compared with 40% for financial wellbeing, 36% for physical wellbeing and 34% for career wellbeing.
Nearly half of employers have taken steps to develop a mental health strategy. Although 90% offer an employee assistance program and 59% provide virtual or telephonic mental health counselling, only 30% offer mental health training for managers, leaders or HR. The gap suggests that providing resources is only part of the challenge; employers must also help people recognize, access and use them.
Financial wellbeing support is less common. Forty-six per cent of employers offer financial-planning resources and 41% provide financial-literacy resources or seminars, while only 3% offer an emergency savings program.
“Benefits strategy increasingly connects directly to workforce strategy,” Beech said. “Healthcare concerns, financial pressure and mental health challenges don’t stop when the workday begins. Employers need to ensure their investments are accessible, understood and aligned with the areas of greatest need.”
Employers preserve core coverage
Despite rising costs, employers have largely maintained broad health and dental coverage. Extended healthcare coverage is offered by 98%, and only one in 10 uses an annual deductible. More than half of employers fully fund the premium, while 42% share the cost with employees.
Dental coverage is similarly widespread, with 96% offering a plan and more than four in five using no annual dental deductible. However, many coverage limits have changed little as fee guides, utilization and treatment costs have increased, meaning the same maximum may cover less care over time.
Rather than making broad cuts, employers are using targeted measures such as coinsurance, annual maximums and health spending accounts. One in three combines a traditional benefits plan with a spending account, giving employees greater flexibility while helping employers manage costs.
Together, the findings point to a more deliberate approach to benefits management — one focused less on adding programs and more on improving the value of existing investments.
ABOUT THE REPORT
Gallagher’s 2026 Workforce Trends Series — Benefits Benchmarks report is based on responses from 674 employers participating in the Canadian Benefits Strategy & Benchmarking Survey, fielded from March through April 2026. Respondents represented organizations of varying sizes and industries across Canada; 74% were for-profit and 26% were nonprofit. Results reflect the experiences and practices reported by participants and may not represent all Canadian employers.
ABOUT GALLAGHER
Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. (NYSE:AJG), a global insurance brokerage, risk management and consulting services firm, is headquartered in Rolling Meadows, Illinois. Gallagher provides these services in approximately 130 countries around the world through its owned operations and a network of correspondent brokers and consultants.
Source : Gallagher





